Should You Buy a Cottage or Second Property This Summer

Andra Arnold • July 11, 2025

Summer is prime time for dreaming about lazy lake days, campfires, and weekends away from the city — which often leads to the question: Should I buy a cottage or second property this summer?

While recreational real estate can be a fantastic investment, there are important factors to weigh before taking the plunge. Here’s what to keep in mind:


1. Affordability and Financing

Cottages and second homes typically require a larger down payment than primary residences (often 20% or more), and interest rates on vacation properties may be slightly higher. Make sure to budget for insurance, maintenance, and potential seasonal costs — from road upkeep to winterizing.


2. Location, Location, Location

Think about how often you’ll realistically visit. A three-hour drive might sound fine in theory but could become a burden over time. Look at travel times, road conditions, and year-round accessibility, especially if you plan to use it in winter.


3. Rental Income Potential

Many buyers offset cottage costs by renting them out part-time. If you’re considering this, research local bylaws around short-term rentals and weigh whether you’re comfortable sharing your getaway with strangers.


4. Maintenance Considerations

Seasonal properties need just as much care as a primary home — sometimes more. Septic systems, docks, well water, or shoreline erosion all come with responsibilities. Factor in maintenance time and costs to protect your investment.


5. Lifestyle Fit

Is a cottage really your dream, or would you prefer traveling to different spots each year? Consider whether you’re ready for the commitment of returning to the same place versus the freedom of booking rentals in new destinations.


Final Thoughts

A second property can be a wonderful investment and a treasured gathering place for family and friends — if it fits your lifestyle, budget, and future plans. As always, talk to a local real estate expert to explore options, market trends, and hidden gems that might surprise you. We are happy to point you in the direction of a trusted realtor.

Meet the Andra Arnold Team

A group of people are posing for a picture in a park.

Andra Arnold & Associates are a Top Rated, Award-Winning Guelph real estate team that has a passion for helping people. We truly live by our motto “Here to Help”. Our team brings quality expertise to our clients’ buying and selling experiences. The team's dedication, eagerness to help, and experience allow clients navigate one of life’s biggest decisions!

Check Out Our Featured Listings

A view of a city from the roof of a building.

More blog posts on buying and selling real estate



Aerial view of Guelph with a river, bridge, and tall buildings surrounded by trees.
By Andra Arnold October 1, 2025
Explore the history of downtown Guelph. From John Galt’s vision to iconic landmarks, markets, and heritage sites, discover the Royal City’s timeless charm.
Cityscape with river, trees, buildings, including a tall church spire and a modern glass building.
By Andra Arnold October 1, 2025
Plan your first visit to Downtown Guelph with must-see landmarks, food spots, shops, and seasonal events. Explore history, culture, and local charm.
By Andra Arnold September 3, 2025
Discover key insights from the Guelph real estate market in August 2025. Sales dipped 26% from July, while prices held steady with a 2.8% month-over-month rise. Learn what this means for buyers and sellers heading into the fall market.
Aerial view of a residential neighbourhood, dense with trees and houses under a bright blue sky.
By Andra Arnold September 2, 2025
Discover Old University in Guelph, historic homes, walkable amenities, and a competitive real estate market make this neighbourhood one of the city’s most desirable places to live.
Aerial view of a residential neighbourhood with many trees, houses, and a distant industrial area on
By Andra Arnold August 31, 2025
Explore Riverside Park in Guelph. History, amenities, lifestyle, and real estate insights. Discover why this riverfront community is one of the city’s most sought-after neighbourhoods.
Aerial view of Guelph's St Patrick's Ward neighbourhood
By Andra Arnold August 18, 2025
If you’ve spent any time in Guelph, you’ve probably heard people talk about “The Ward.” Officially called St. Patrick’s Ward, this neighbourhood sits just east of downtown and has a personality all its own.
More Posts